Should fighters be looked at as role models?

A lot of kids grow up watching sports, and many of those kids choose a favorite athlete in the sports they watch. I had a Mario Lemieux poster on my wall growing up, my friends had posters of Michael Jordan, Emmitt Smith, John Elway and countless others on theirs. They seemed larger than life and for myself and my friends, those athletes were who we wanted to be growing up.

With that fame, there seemingly comes a level of responsibility as an athlete. If you know that kids are looking up to you, then it only makes sense that you should behave in a way that makes you worthy of being looked up to.

But is that fair? And if it is fair, how far does it extend? Do we limit it to "mainstream" athletes? Those in the NBA, NFL, MLB, NHL, etc? What about MMA fighters? Does it extend to them?

This comes to mind recently because of the actions, both inside and outside of the cage, of one of the sports most popular fighters.

Jon "Bones" Jones may be the greatest combat athlete the world has ever seen. Since his UFC debut in 2008, Jones has torn through the UFC light heavyweight division in brutal fashion. The lone blemish on his 23-1 record is a disqualification in 2009. Other than that, his list of opponents is a who's who of MMA legends and top contenders.

It all came off the rails in April of 2015 when Jones was involved in a hit and run with a pregnant woman in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Jones was stripped of his title and suspended for six months. He would return to action in April of 2016, defeating Ovince Saint Preux at UFC 197. Everything looked to be back on track for Jones until he was again stripped of his title and suspended for a year after a USADA (US Anti Doping Agency) violation. His latest return took place at UFC 214 where he would defeat Daniel Cormier to recapture his UFC light heavyweight title. Again, everything looked to be back in Jones favor. However, he tested positive again from a drug test right before the fight and is now facing suspension again.

Should we have expected Jones to be a role model?

If so then he's obviously failed in that role.

But why should we look to athletes in a sport where the main objective is to render your opponent unconscious to be role models?

I would argue that if you're watching MMA in hopes of finding a role model then you're watching for the wrong reasons. While there are plenty of honorable and admirable fighters out there, it's not exactly a civilized sport.

Comments

Is Georges St-Pierre the greatest of all time?

Georges St-Pierre made his professional MMA debut in 2002. From 2002 through 2013, he amassed a record of 25-2 and became the longest reigning UFC Welterweight champion in history. One of his two losses in that span came at the hands of Matt Hughes in 2004, a future UFC Hall of Famer and multi-time champion, widely considered the greatest Welterweight on the planet prior to St-Pierre's rise to prominence. His other loss came in 2007 to Matt Serra in what is widely regarded as one of the biggest upsets in MMA history. St-Pierre would avenge that loss in dominating fashion just over a year later in April of 2008, after defeating Josh Koscheck and Matt Hughes in back to back fights in 2007. The victory over Koscheck at UFC 74 moved St-Pierre's record to 14-2. That victory came in 2007. He would remain undefeated in 11 more fights between 2007 and 2013, moving his record to 25-2. Most of his wins came in dominating fashion despite not finishing an opponent since UFC 94 in ...

When should fighters walk away from the sport?

Mark Hunt and Antonio "Bigfoot" Silva engage in a brutal war at UFC 193 in November of 2015. Combat sports are inherently dangerous. The entire point of the sport is to render your opponent unable to continue before he can do the same to you. So it's no surprise that many fighters don't have long careers, at least at the top of the sport, and those that do tend to show the effects of their brutal craft. But when should a fighter decide enough is enough and walk away? Antonio "Bigfoot" Silva has been fighting professionally since 2005 and has a record of 19-12-1. His claim to fame is being the first man to defeat the legendary Fedor Emelianenko when he submitted the Russian in 2011. After entering the UFC in 2012, Silva only managed three wins from 2012 to 2016. He's lost eight of his last ten fights and has been knocked out in all but one of those losses after only being knocked out twice in his career previously. In recent fights, Silva has lo...

Knockouts vs Submissions

When it comes to MMA, everyone loves a finish, whether it comes by KO/TKO or submission. But if given the option, how would you prefer to see a fight end? Obviously, a one-punch knockout or a head kick finish is highly entertaining and can make fans jump out of their seats in reaction. That's what I believe most fans would choose if they had to pick how a fight should end. The act of rendering an opponent unconscious with a single strike or a combination of strikes draws people back to the gladiator days (luckily without the death and dismemberment). It's made more exciting by the fact that a knockout can come out of nowhere (see Uriah Hall's finish in UFC Pittsburgh). Submissions though, there's something to be said for forcing your opponent to quit in a fight. Whether it's a case of prolonged grappling leading to an eventual submission or sinking something like a guillotine choke in when the opponent goes for a takedown, giving your opponen...

Tales From The Cage

Search This Blog